Showing posts with label What we learned. Show all posts
Showing posts with label What we learned. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Minnesota @ Wisconsin: What We Learned

Ahhhhrrrrg! The RED - it burns!
Photo by JT

Another Axe game come and gone.  Another football loss to the Badgers.  We keep this up a few more years and they might actually end up with the all-time wins edge that we’ve maintained for so long.  That has always been the last refuge of the Gopher fan assaulted by Badger ‘we always beat Minnesota’ nonsense.  If we lose that edge we have nothing else.  Yes, 6 National Titles and all that are nice, but they garner us zero respect these days.  Which is not to say that we shouldn’t bring it up, we should embrace our history as Coach Brew reminded us all when he first came to Minnesota.

And now, we need to remind him that by embracing our rich football history, its time for him to leave at the end of the 2010 season.  And by that I mean – we’re 0-7 in our historic rivalry games (sorry PSU, I’m not counting you and that lame-o bell, but that would make us 0-9).  These are two teams that we proudly hold the all-time wins edge over through the decades, and it must be maintained.  Brew can’t win the ‘trinket games’, to borrow a phrase from Grinnin’ Glen Mason, and that’s a history this program can no longer afford to continue creating.  I must admit that I might not have felt this way, had we seen another typical Brewster-era Wisconsin/Minnesota game, you know – where we actually had at least a chance to win in the end.  But that’s not what happened.  We got spanked, and couldn’t even muster a strong enough effort to be competitive.

I said to KZ in the closing moments of this game that this showing against Wisconsin was the last nail pounded into Brewster’s waiting coffin.  I only half-heartedly believe this, because of the whole ‘outgoing University president, lame-duck AD’ issue going on in the background.  It seems likely Maturi would be pressured by the big boosters to can Coach Brew by the end of the year, but whether he breaks down and actually does it is another issue.  But even if we go winless the rest of the way, as long as Brewster doesn’t lose control of the team, I can see that there are a few pros to keeping him around for fulfill his final contract year.  For me, they’re just not enough to warrant a 5th year.  Yes, I’m aware I’m late to the ‘fire Brewster’ party and I’ll admit he had me pretty snowed in years 1-3.  I was happily awash in the positivity that Glen Mason never provided.  And while I've been critical of Brewster in the past for his inability to maintain continuity at coordinator, and some of his hires (Jedd Fisch anyone?), I've given him more of a pass than I should for his inability to win games, using patience as a shield, thinking there was something at work we just needed to wait for it.  

However, you won’t catch me booing or chanting for Coach Brew’s head, as I still have a high amount of respect for him, and all the hard work he puts in, despite the frustrating results.  And I won’t give up on this team.  I like too many of our young players and am too emotionally invested in quit on them now.   But I digress, back to last Saturday’s game.

As tough as it was to watch (aside from the decent 2nd quarter showing) there were at least a few enjoyable moments of this game.

What I liked:
1)    The new white helmets to go with the all-white jersey and pants.  Very sharp.  I wasn’t  a huge fan of the white/white road duds, but add the white helmets and suddenly they become far more fashionable. 
2)    The play of Da’Jon McKnight, Eric Lair, and MarQueis Gray.  I called for a ‘breakout game’ for McKnight, and while 2 catches for 50 yards is certainly not that, I did get two magnificent TD catches in garbage time.  The other 2 made some nice catches as well, and I'm really liking that TE screen that they run for Lair.
3)    Bielema deciding to go for 2 while up 25 with 6 minutes to go.  Not that I liked the call, but I did like what resulted from the call. By Bielema going for two, we got to - A) stop them from getting 2 more points (phew); B) See Brewster get fired up and pissed off (I love surly Brewster) and; C) it will reinforce the rest of the Big Ten coaching ranks rumored dislike of Bielema. National media consensus also seems to be that it was a asshole call.  Not shocking though, we’re talking about a guy who went to Iowa here.  What goes around comes around.
4)    The number of frosh and sophs on the field during the game who got to experience the bitterness of losing the axe first hand.  Hopefully these kids will remember well, and win it back soon!

What I loathed:
1)    Getting off to a solid start running the ball into Wisconsin territory, only to have to settle for a field goal because we decided to throw the ball 3 times in a row.
2)    The blown call on the Kendricks fumble caused after ‘forward progress’ early in the 3rd on the Badgers opening possession.  It was a clear strip and fumble.  And there was no audible whistle on the broadcast until the ball came out.  A garbage call, and a big momentum changer if it goes Minnesota’s way.
3)    Going for it on 4th and 2 at the fifty with 10:30 to go in the 2nd.  Yes we were down 14, but not getting the conversion there and giving the Badgers a short a field could have put us down 21-0 and the game essentially out of reach very early. Luckily we picked it up, and got a stay of execution.
4)  The lack of energy out of the Gophers.  Maybe I mistook it for the team trying to control their emotions, but only Weber seemed really pumped up.
5)    All the damn red.  ARGGGHH it burns my eyes!

And what did I learn?  Well every week it’s something new. I learned that our trio of receivers, McKnight, Gray, and Lair could actually become one of the Big Ten's best units, and Gray's play in particular will make it tough to send him under center next year (unless he becomes the next Denard Robinson?).  And I learned that turning off the TV immediately after the clock reads 0:00 is a good choice when we lose this rivalry game (I used to watch the post game celebrations as penance).

I also got some reminders of stuff I already knew.  Namely, that stats lie, and no amount of can-do attitude will necessarily translate into a win.  Case in point - in Adam Weber's 4 games versus Wisconsin, he's put up some impressive numbers - 63 completions, 1,074 yards and 11 TDs (1 rushing), with only 4 interceptions.  Pretty good QB #s, and it means nothing as Web is 0-4 to show for it.  And speaking of Web, all this nonsensical talk about his NFL prospects should shut down until he can throw a football accurately.  I don't care what Peyton Manning said about him at his camp, he's passing the ball at under 60% a clip, and for college that ain't good. Accuracy has a high value in the NFL, and Weber doesn't have it. And lastly, I was again reminded what a jackhole Bielema is (although, admittedly I hadn't completely forgotten).

A trip to West Lafayette and a battle with Purdon't coming up next.  Time to jump off the mat, snatch that hammer out of Purdue Pete's hand, and give the Boilers the beatdown that my safety school so richly deserves.

I'm not sayin', I'm just sayin':  Bielema claims he went for 2 in the 4th, up 25 (score was 41 - 16) with 6 and a half to go because that's what his "how to be an asshole" chart says.  The over/under on the game was 58, and getting 2 would have put the total score on the 'over'.  Obviously moot, once Minnesota scored its last TD, but an interesting coincidence? 

Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Northwestern @ Minnesota - What we learned

Another loss piled on to an already swiftly sinking season.  Of course, some may have already declared the season officially ‘sunk’.  I hadn’t prior to this game, but I’m almost out of buoyancy.  That is to say the season hasn’t completely gone below the waterline for me, but its damn close.  Getting blown out at Wisconsin this week could be the final torpedo to put my last modicum of hope under.  Let’s hope that doesn’t happen.  I don’t want to think about how tough it will be to get excited for the Purdue game the following week if we’re 1-5 and axe-less.  On a fun Gopherhole.com thread started last week, someone asked what movie quote best described the Gopher’s football program over the past several decades.  My response?
Gopher fans - "I think you know how this is going to end.  Don't you?"
- Anton Chigur (Javier Bardem) from 'No Country for Old Men'
Despite a good chance to win against Northwestern, didn’t the whole thing go down just the way you figured?  I know it did for me. And sadly, that’s the exact feeling I started to develop at the back half of the Mason era, but really you could apply it to just about any full season under his tenure.  Now that feeling has crept in to my mindset in the Brewster era. 
The undefeated Wildcats came in and showed themselves to be who we thought they were (and we let ‘em off the hook), a vulnerable and beatable team that was still relatively untested.  A team that Minnesota could best, if only a few things went our way.  And this time, a number of things indeed did go our way – primarily the turnover margin, but also a missed XP, frequent Wildcat penalties, and some blown coverage in the Northwestern secondary. 
The Gopher defense was again overmatched across from the skilled Dan Persa, but they managed to turn over the ‘Cats enough at the right times to allow for the offense to keep pace. Persa was able to do damage with his legs, but the Wildcat RBs were largely held in check.  The front four (Smash Bros. et al) did generate some pressure, but Persa is very quick to flee on the first sign of pocket collapse and run.  Definitely a strength for him in the college game, but it will be considered a weakness come draft day for him, as he didn’t seem to be willing to stand in the pocket and deliver the ball as coverage breaks down.  Cosgrove dialed up some appropriately timed blitzes, (maybe too few?) and the one that resulted in a TD was simply tough luck as Ebert managed to muscle the ball from Collado on what appeared to be in near perfect 1-on-1 coverage.    
Pre-game at the Stub & Herbs's back alley - photo by TKL
And with 2 minutes to go, even a freakily fortunate forward fumble advanced by the Gophs to the 40 (which the TV broadcast crew spent surprisingly little time looking at) still wasn’t enough good fortune to put the Gophers over the top.
The Gopher offense rediscovered their competence for nearly the entire game.  Adam Weber was again secure with the ball, and DeLeon Eskeridge was the prime ballcarrier de jour, with some hard running and nice sidesteps on interior runs that earned him extra yardage.  And it was nice to see the offensive line regain some of their confidence back, and actually started laying wood on some purple jerseys. 
But sadly, all these things listed above were for naught.  With 2 minutes to go, even a freakily fortunate forward fumble advanced by the Gophs to the 40 (which the TV broadcast crew spent surprisingly little time looking at) still wasn’t enough good fortune to put the Gophers over the top.  Incompetence set in for those final 2 minutes, and it was just enough to ensure another loss.  Obviously, based on the ‘Crew’s Brew of the Week’ posted earlier this week, I was surly and furious (pun intended) about the way the last possession went down.  The Strib’s Phil Miller did a nice job breaking down the final 8 plays, coupled with Brewster’s post-game press conference remarks regarding some of the specific play calls.  Read, and you’ll surely find a new irritation for Brewster/Horton (it’s still not clear who’s calling plays in these situations) and their crunch time way of thinking.  I realize it’s easy to say in hindsight, but I think I could have come out of this loss feeling much better if we at least had been able to attempt a field goal or take a last second stab down the field.
It’s simply amazing to me to see how the Gophers fail to execute time and time again in the big moments of the game. Is it inexperience? Coaching? Are they actually overachieving in these close games (I shudder to think if this is true)?  A combination of all these?  I’m sure I don’t know, but losses like these continue to pound nails into the Brewster regime’s coffin.  To come out prepared and able to give a quality Big Ten opponent the fight of their life, and shoot yourself in the foot with a chance to win in the closing moments has got to hurt the psyche of a probably already mentally fragile team. 
The 'Block M', from the NW corner -  photo by TKL
And what was learned from this, yet another tough loss?  Well, the Wildcats apparently don’t care too much about ball security.  They also still don’t have any running backs that could start on any other Big Ten team.  But then the Gophers don’t seem to care about laying a proper block in crunch time either and that’s what in the end really counted.  And finally, I learned that even though I let a well-behaved fan and friend who roots for the other team into our stadium with tickets to my seats, I still feel a little guilty about it.    
This coming Saturday’s prospects? With the Badgers coming home off a tough road loss to the Spartans last week, I feel a Camp Randall spanking coming on.  Then again, the Gophers have always played the Badgers tough and close (but always lost) under Brewster’s tenure. Vegas has the line opening up in the 20-21 point range which seems a smidge too high to me, I think +14.5 is more appropriate for the Gophs, but that line may shrink over the week.
Preview coming on Thursday night, along with Badger alum Roger Murdock’s take on the game.

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Northern Illinois @ Minnesota: What we learned

This young Gopher fan found better things to watch than the 4th Qtr
Photo by JT
Another gut wrenching loss.  What can you say that hasn't already been uttered in an overheard expletive laced tirade on the post-game walk to your car. Another glorious evening for football at The Bank, made ruinous by poor run blocking, and even poorer tackling. Sigh.  Losing at home is not a habit I'd like to see develop.  But it's happening.  At least last year, we respectably defended our home turf with a winning record (4-3), with respectable losses to Cal and Wisconsin, and Illinois in a headscratcher.  We seemed to own the night with the Air Force and Michigan State wins with some timely (if not lucky) bounces that went our way.  That all seems so distant now.  Truly, my confidence in the Brewster regime is all but dead.  Only an improbable run in the conference schedule will restore it to at least measurable levels.

Now NIU is no pushover MAC team, but they certainly aren't USC either.  Yet they came in and pretty much did the same damn thing to us that SoCal did.  Ran the ball down our throats.  Life seemed so much simpler 2 weeks ago, when we could just blame our pass defense on the inexperience of Christyn Lews and James Manuel (or conversley the suspension of Theret and the injury to Royston).  Now that we've been gashed in both the pass and run, the defensive troubles seem so much more, well, troubling.  The Huskies managed 34 points on the Gophers, in only 23 minutes of possession.  Disgraceful.

Clearly NIU head coach Jerry Kill saw something on our tape vs. USC that he liked.  I'm guessing it was the way our linebackers seem to always be 1 or 2 steps out of position, leaving major running holes wide open. Going into this game I thought we were going to get 'Dante Warren-ed' to death by a better and more experienced Chandler Harnish. Turns out, they didn't even need him to do much more than be a caretaker for the offense, letting Chad Spann carry the load.  In that limited time NIU had the ball, Spann managed to rack up 223 yards on just 15 carries.  Yeah, that's nearly 11 ypc.  You'd think Barry Sanders or Gale Sayers was lining up across from us with those kind of numbers. And Harnish's legs? Well, he seemed to be the one player we actually did scheme for, and his runs were held in check. But that isn't  worth much when the halfback lining up behind him can just get you 10 yards a crack.
This looks like a stout  bunch in the Maroon.  Key word - 'looks'.
Photo by JT

At the beginning of this season, I really did believe that the front 7 of this team would continually improve and ultimately become the strength of this defense.  They certainly appear to be an athletic enough group.  Chalk their performance up to inexperience and poor coaching?  I suppose so, but my confidence in Cosgrove is virtually gone, to say nothing of Brewster.  Last year I feld like Cosgrove had really maximized the talent on our defense, making them a cohesive unit that kept us in games all season.  This year, I am really at loss for what has happened so far, and how things will progress/regress into th future.  Perhaps all the Nebraska and Wisconsin Cosgrove-haters  who warned us had it right?  
 
On offense, OC Horton again tried valiantly to establish the run, but simply could not. Our longest run from scrimmage was a measly 12 yards, and the one explosive run we did muster (Bennett's 3rd quarter sprint to the east endzone) was called back on a hold. NIU's defensive rotations (6-man line shifts) seemed to keep them from getting worn down later in the game, and kept running room difficult all game.  And once again, Weber was serviceable and didn't do anything to cost us the game (although that desparation shovel pass was an absolutely dreadful decision).  He padded his stats again late in the game on some nice drives that ultimately just closed the margin of victory for NIU.  MarQueis again looked the part of a potential All-Big Ten WR (maybe Dave Mona wasn't insane for claiming that?). 
Thumbs down Gophers, you let my boys down
Photo by JT
 
But I need to stay positive here. There were some aspects about last Saturday's gameday that I did like:
1) The weather. Just about a perfect evening for football. Fireworks at the half were nice too.
2) My entire family taking in a Gopher football game (as we like to do as a full group annually), including my two boys getting to go to their first game at The Bank!
3) The Ski-U-Brat. Tasty, but the brat itself needs to be a bit larger, to match the scale of the bun.
4) Fresh mini donuts. Sweet and delicious. 
5) "Goldy's Groove" in the 3rd Quarter. Attention TCF Bank Stadium Operations Manger(s) - keep this feature. I'm all about anyway we can incorporate Earth, Wind, and Fire in to gameday.  And 'Let's Groove Tonight' did inspire some excellent fan dancing.  How about next week we rock Funkadelic's 'One Nation Under a Groove'?
6) MarQueis Gray. He's real good at WR. He's not fumbling the ball. And Weber is finding him  I like it. 

So there were plenty of reasons to enjoy myself. Just not football. Well, except for MarQueis Gray.  He can actually play football.

Fireworks. I enjoy them even when losing.  Photo by JT
So how is this team going fare against Northwestern?  The 4-0 Wildcats haven't won a single game convincingly against less than impressive opponents. Like most of our games versus the Mildcats, I expect a shootout.  And tomorrow we should have our first of several weekly opposing views from a fan of our current Big Ten opponent.  This week, my friend and Northwestern alum, TKL will be putting together a preview of his own of the game. He's also using my tickets, as I can't get up to the Twin Cities for a 4th straight weekend. Before you scoff at my selling season ticket seats to the enemy, remember this is a Northwestern guy, not some Badger jackhole or Hawkeye d-bag.  And Northwestern alumni will always beat the rest of the Big Ten alums in 'gentlemanly-like behavior' at all sporting events.  Except for that one NU fan who got ejected from Welsh-Ryan Arena last year for yelling at Ed Hightower.  But then, who hasn't yelled at Ed Hightower?  So no worries, he'll behave himself and be respectful.  And he's graciously agreed to share with us what he thinks of our new digs and the upgraded 'college football on campus' atmosphere.

And what did we learn?  I learned that we can't even stop a MAC team's running game.  I learned that our offensive line cannot create running lanes against a MAC team.  But I also learned that the most beautiful of autumn nights cannot quite be ruined by gross incompetence.   And finally, I learned that I learned that having your wife and kids smiling at the game only goes so far, and that eventually you just need to abandon your family and grab a beer.  Thanks for being there Mr. Omar Douglas Redux.  That Surly Furious on tap at Stub and Herbs we had went a long way to soothe my nerves.  And as my favorite beer, Surly Furious shall become the first of our Crew's Brews we highlight, as we suffer through this season and find different beers to ease the pain (stay tuned for more of our GEHG's Crew's Brews). Ethanol is needed to survive our Big Ten season and brutal remaining home schedule.  Beer is the vehicle.


Wednesday, September 22, 2010

USC @ Minnesota: What we learned

The GEGH crew sets up in the Ski-U-Mah Lot - photo by JT
This Saturday gave us yet another beautiful day at The Bank, and with a quality if not villainous opponent in USC coming to town, most Gopher fans that attended seemed able to put aside last weeks horrid loss and rally behind the Gophs for another game.  A win over the rule breakers from SoCal would go some significant distance in helping rerail the season.  The pre-game tailgating scene in the Ski-U-Mah Lot was terrific, and there were plenty of smiling faces, back slapping, and booze to go around.  Gopher Tailgate Nation was out in force again, and happy to be there, despite our recent woes.  Our GEGH group assembled a 3-State alumni contingent, and had a terrific time eating, drinking, and carousing.  I was, in particular, happy to spread the joy that is Cuervo 1800 Reposado with my colleagues (listen up Cuervo, you can advertise on here for free as far as I'm concerned).

With the exception of one irritable dude wearing a nice Chris Darkins, Jim Wacker-era jersey who rebuffed us for our "Darkins! Darkins! Darkins!" chant, most everybody rolling thru the lot appeared to be in good spirits (whatever, the guy obviously didn't know who #44 actually was). Most were expecting the worst and hoping for the best.  It seemed like almost a given that the Gophers would be down multiple touchdowns early, and it would get worse from there.  I was scoffed at by many for my bold (but ultimately foolish) 31-30 Gophers victory prediction.  And during the game, there seemed to be some in attendance that were actually rooting for a blowout loss, so they could feel more validated in their "Fire Brewster Now!" position.  But more importantly, the vast bulk of fans that attended the game were clearly here to support the Maroon and Gold for better or worse.
The ladies love themselves some Gopher Tailgating - photo by Mar

The game itself was pretty entertaining, at least for 3 quarters.  The Gophers hung tough for much of the game, over came some ill-timed mistakes (and flukey bad luck).  But it could only last so long. USC had the superior talent, and eventually found a way to overcome their own assemblage of mistakes (penalties and interceptions).  I read somewhere out there in the blogosphere that this game felt like the Cal game last season.  I'm inclined to agree.  Everyone's favorite 'close personal friend' of a columnist, Sid Hartman suggested that the loss hinged on 3 plays.  I'd suggest that it was really just two plays though; 1) The Jewhan Edwards facemask on the 3rd and long sack, and; 2) rather than the 97-yard kick return TD, the Gophers complete inability to answer that counter-punch with a score of their own following it (another 3-and-out).  That 3-and-out was particularly damning, as it came AFTER Kirkwood gained a tough 8 yards off right tackle on 1st down.

But for once this season, I was not completely mortified by the pass defense.  Yes they gave up 2 big TD passes, but for them to hold Matt Barkley, a shoe-in top 5 NFL draft pick, to under 200 yards in the air and pick him off twice was an accomplishment.  No doubt Kyle Theret's return to the starting lineup was a big reason why.  Unfortunately, once Kiffin figured out that running repeatedly with big back Allen Bradford was the way to go, we were already down and had to play catchup.  My worry earlier in the week had been proven out.  Recent history indicates that these bigger running backs seem to give us trouble, and Bradford and his line had their way with the Gophs through the latter stages of the game.  This was culminated by the 56-yard touchdown run Bradford had for USC's final score, where he dashed down the north sideline completely untouched from start to finish.  Obviously, the run defense really struggled, especially up front later in the game, hardly getting a hand on Tyler or Bradford on several runs.
Barkley wings his first TD of the game - photo by JT

The offense had its moments, but the running game disappointed me.  Bennett tweaked his ankle early and had no impact on this game.  DeLeon was who he always seems to be, a ball-secure first guy without great burst or vision.  Donnell Kirkwood had a few nice runs, but they came too infrequently to allow for the ball-control that Brewster and Horton were clearly seeking with their gameplan.  What really bothered me though wasn't the perceived 'over-commitment' to the run, but rather the lack of creativity and variability in the run calls.  After re-watching the game, I noticed that about 80% of the runs seemed to be between the tackles, and most often just simple dives.  No counters, very little trap blocking, and we didn't see much of the shovel and screen passes either.  Was there something in the scouting report that told the staff that running up the gut was the way to make hay against this squad?  Not sure, but we sure did like the dive play.  The other thing that struck me was that none of our 3 running backs seemed to really even look to make a cut or

Weber again completed a little over half his throws, and did his usual of making just enough good plays in between the bad ons to keep me from being completely frustrated with him.  His interception right before the half was ridiculously bad, as was best served to just throw the ball out of bounds (has Weber EVER done that?) even if it was 3rd down. MarQueis and McKnight looked pretty good when Weber managed to find them.  If McKnight can make that over the outside shoulder catch on the sideline routinely, then he needs to run that route more often in games.

Favorite play on offense:  The great catch in my corner of the endzone by McKnight was the BEST play of the day for the Gophs, but it wasn't my favorite.  That honor goes to the Kirkwood 15-yard run at midfield that might have resulted in a TD had he been able to put a move on his closest defender.  The left side of the O-line opened up a HUGE hole (see photo), and Donnell had lots of green in front of him.  Instead he initiated contact and bowled over the safety.  At the time (early 2nd quarter), I liked the message it sent. In hindsight, he's gotta come up with a Playstation move to freeze that guy.
Look at that hole - how did Kirkwood NOT score - photo by JT

Favorite play on defense:  Manuel's interception of Barkley to end USC's opening drive of the 3rd quarter.  Anthony Jacobs applies the pressure up in Barkley's grill, and Manuel comes over to the TE down the seam and snatches the wobbler out of the air to send the momentum back to the Gophers.

So what did we learn in this, the 3rd week of a still young (yet already exhausting) season?  Many things as usual, perhaps the most important being that tailgating for an afternoon game is preferably to the 11AM starts.  No need to get up at 7AM.  You can leisurely get up at a sane hour and make your way down to Stadium Village with plenty of tailgating hours in front of you. I learned that MarQueis Gray appears to be the go-to receiver for Weber already.  What that means for MG's QB career is unknown, but right now Gray looks like he might become too valuable at WR to become our starting QB if (and only if) Moses Alipate is game-ready in 2011.   I learned that Kyle Theret was definitely missed, perhaps more than I wanted to believe.  I learned that Horton still really does want to keep running the ball, but not in any real creative fashion.  And finally, I learned that handing out a free magazine in the student section is a bad idea.  How we didn't get penalized for all the mags that landed on the field (even during play) was beyond me.  Chalk that one up to having a Big Ten ref crew, I guess.

NIU preview will be up late tomorrow/early Friday, and although I called for the let down loss after USC, I feel a win coming on before plunging into the Big Ten season.

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

South Dakota @ Minnesota - What we learned (and where it went wrong).

o
Gary Tinsely fills the 'A-Gap', all other defenders? Occupado. - photo by JT 
Why do the football gods hate me so much?  Why?  After torturing me on another beautiful Saturday at The Bank, 24 hours later, they decide to take away an improbable opening road win from my Honolulu Blue and Silver by robbing Calvin Johnson of a game-winning TD catch.  Oh, and the cherry on top was the loss of Matthew Stafford for 4-6 weeks.  I don't know what I did to deserve this, but it must have been pretty bad.

As much as I wanted to write up my postgame 'What we learned' post on Sunday evening, I just couldn't bring myself to sit at the computer and think about this game. I needed some time to forget and feel sorry for myself (and watch the game a second time on the DVR).  Well, that and I was  pretty tired from the trip back home.

First off, let's give credit where credit is due.  South Dakota came to play, and executed their offense very efficiently, despite of a lack of experience at several positions, including QB.  This did not appear to be the team that got bullied for 60 minutes versus Central Florida.  Second, let me step out and state that I was pretty much wrong about everything in my prediction of this game (although I did come very close to the Gopher's point total).  No establishing the the run.  No imposing of our will.  No carries for Kirkwood (WTH?). No wearing the opponent down and dominating the 4th quarter.  And most obviously, no win.  Instead there was panic on offense.  Panic to score, thanks to the ineptitude of the defense.

As I walked into TCF Bank Stadium at around 10:50 AM that morning, I felt pretty good (aside from the 2 and a half pounds of eggs, cheese, sausage, bacon, and potatoes courtesy of  Sally's Game Day Skillet Scramblers).  The sun was shining, the student section was actually filling up, and people seemed pretty excited about the 1 and 0 Golden Gophers.  But by about the 8 minute mark, the mood was already starting to sour.  The Gophers started out nicely, and looked the part of the more dominant team.  Stoudemire got us rolling with a nice opening kick return across the fifty, and although the first drive was a little more pass-heavy than expected, it stalled but the result was still 3 points.  On defense, things started solid as well. Keanon Cooper got a TFL to open the game, and the Gophers held on a 3rd and short to force a quick 3 and out.  Chris Ganious was being contained and it looked like South Dakota would have to rely on their QB to generate some offense.  That ended up being the worst thing that could have happened for the Gophers.  Coyote QB, Dante Warren was up to the challenge, and Cosgrove, Lee, and Brewster couldn't scheme up anything to stop his legs or his arm.  Two flag routes and 11 minutes later, the Coyotes were up 14-3, and everybody was scratching their heads as to how this could be happening.
Tiree drops Six -  photo by JT

But the Gophs responded, coming right back with a beautiful 49-yard TD pass on the post to Troy Stoudemire.  And on the ensuing USD possession, Michael Carter picked off Warren.  The momentum swing was on.  Or so it seemed.  From there out, for every terrific play Minnesota made on offense was pretty much matched by the Coyotes.  Post Carter INT, Tiree Eure dropped a go-ahead TD pass (see photo on right), and Weber missed a wide open MarQueis Gray on a comeback by sailing the ball 12 feet over his head.  Ellestad completed the trifecta of poor execution with another wide left FG miss.

From this point the defense really started to struggle.  Missed tackles and blown coverage being the main issue. Having already seen the RB screen once and getting fooled, the Gophs again got suckered by the clear path to the QB, this time yielding a 26-yard TD scamper.  Now fairly shocked late in the 2nd quarter, I couldn't think things could go much worse until I saw Weber cough up the ball on a nice scramble, well past the 1st down marker when he could have slid.   Down 21-10, it was a nightmare half to be sure.  I can only imagine what Brewster's halftime speech must have been like.
Still, the game was in reach, and even though a blowout win was a distant memory, there was a feeling that with some key halftime adjustments on defense,  we could dominate the second half and salvage an ugly victory.  Once again my faith was misplaced.


Much to my surprise, the students showed up in force - photo by JT
 Things only got worse on defense, and the rest of the way the Gopher offense had to frantically try and put enough points on the board to close the gap.  The Minnesota defensive backs gave massive cushions to the USD receivers, and were regularly beat on quick slants and short comebacks that extended drives.  And while the defense seemed capable of stopping Ganious on the ground (16 carries for just 8 years), they couldn't track down Warren on bootlegs, nor could they cover any deep routes down the middle.  Essentially all USD had to do to score was run just enough to keep Minnesota honest, and then just strike downfield or roll out on a naked boot.  And that 4th and short that Warren scored on untouched?  Chalk that one up to Cosgrove for overcommitting the defense to the run up the middle.

And as admirable as it was to see Jeff Horton and Adam Weber do their damnedest to get the Gophers to close the gap, the defense couldn't produce enough stops to get the Gophers that last possession they needed to pull ahead.  Brewster's decision to try and convert a 4th and 2 with 12 minutes left on the USD 24 was perhaps questionable, but the kick was going into the wind, and Ellestad has been money to miss from outside of 40 yards all season (0 for 3).  This kind of talk is, of course, pretty damn ridiculous though, when you're talking about needing to play catchup against an FCS opponent (to say nothing of giving up nearly 500 yards of total offense to an FCS opponent).  And so there we were in the final quarter, doing things like lining up for a fake onside kick, making illegal forward laterals, and other such signs of desperation that I hadn't expected to see on this day.  That Sally's Skillet probably should have come back up right around then, but I somehow spared my lovely wife the indignity.  Thank goodness this game was in as beautiful and alcohol-free a setting as it was.  Had I been in the 'Dome, I surely would have been heaving into a urinal trough.  The day and the stadium sent this defeat from 'truly unbearable' to just straight-up 'unbearable'

So what did we learn from this loss?  First and foremost, I found that my seemingly boundless faith in Brewster hath been shaken.  And while he shouldn't be fired midseason (simply not fair to the kids playing for him), you have to wonder now what it will take for him to save his job for the final year of his contract.  Just 2 games into the season, and I'm already more confused by this team than in any other year of the Brewster era.  What are we?  Talented, but horribly inconsistent is what comes to mind. That, or just bad, with a few respectable playmakers.  Neither is a formula for consistent winning.  And now to restore my faith in Coach Brew, it will take a near miraculous remainder of the year (for me, I'd define that as winning 2 of 3 trophy games, and beating Northwestern, Purdue, and Illinois).  The likelihood of that happening would appear slim, but I'll live on hope for now.  Barring a season finish like that, Brewster and the 'U' need to part ways.  There.  I've said it, and quantified it (although I'm not hard and fast on things here, I'll trade a USC or Ohio State win for that rinky-dink Governor's Bell any day of the week.  I also learned that MarQueis Gray is ready for prime time as a receiver, (at least against a I-AA teams).  And last I learned just how much we really do miss Theret and Royston.
GBG, Nate, and 2Mutch sadly reflect on the game - photo by JT

So let me be positive here to close out.  There were a number of good (albeit small) things that can be taken out of this game (believe it or not).
1) The O-line couldn't have pass protected much better.  Web had all day to set up and throw from the pocket
2) For the second game in a row, the Gophers largely avoided the drive-killing penalties that wracked them in previous seasons
3) Favorite play on offense - the trips left formation where Weber found MarQueis down the seam for a nice score in the 3rd
4) Favorite play on defense - Gary Tinsley finally diagnosing the halfback screen and snuffing it out for a loss (3rd time's the charm, right?)
5) The express lanes to get in the stadium at Gates A and E were just that - express.  I walked thru in under 15 seconds with 10 minutes to gametime.  Amazing how quick a line can move when you're not patting down every man, woman, and child.

And now USC comes rolling into town next Saturday, no doubt licking their chops at the prospect of 1,000 yards of total offense.  At this point, I'm just hoping the Gophs can score 30 to match SoCal's 70.  Blowout or no, we'll be getting our tailgate on next week in the Ski-U-Mah lot and enjoying ourselves.  And maybe, just maybe - the gods of football owe me one for last weekend?

Stay tuned for the USC @ Gophers preview to be posted on Friday morning.

Friday, September 3, 2010

Minnesota @ MTSU - What we learned

This kid knows a win when he sees it - photo by JT

Well, that's one win in the books.  Halfway to our Sports Illustrated prediction!

And it felt good too.  There wasn't too much of a bad aftertaste with this victory.  The game wasn't as close as the score indicated, and there were a lot of positives. Before the game started, there was a little nagging worry in the back of my head about how the team would start the season on the road against a respectable opponent.

But the Gophers came out and punched the Blue Raiders right in the mouth on the opening drive.  In the opening play, Bennett took the ball to the right off tackle and Laird, Hoese, and Hughes all laid perfect blocks on their men to spring the play for 32 yards.  Third play from scrimmage?  Student body right, and Bennett goes for another 25 yards.  A fun start to be sure.  And an instant injection of credibility to all the coaching staff who kept stating how the run game would be committed to and improved.  But it wasn't the opening drive that convinced me that Horton and Brew were actually serious about this whole running the ball thing.  It was his play calling in the 2nd and 3rd quarters that had me buying that this team wasn't going to panic and drop Weber into the shotgun for the rest of the way.  He used the run to jab at MTSUs defense in the 3rd, and then had their hands on their hips for the final 15 minutes.  If there's one thing I don't mind learning from a coordinator who spent 6 years as a Badger, its how to close out football games.  And this was textbook domination of time-of-possession.

But not everything with the offense was sunshine and lollipops.  There's still plenty to work on, of course.  The passing game in the first half was rough, largely due to this year's first sighting of 'Bad Web'.  Whether it was season opener jitters or just getting into the swing of playing with live bullets, Adam Weber was off to a rough to start.  In his first throw of the game, he hung Stoudemire out to dry in the endzone on a quick slant between converging defenders.  Luckily he was bailed out by a legit defensive PI call.  From there he went 0 for 4, with accuracy being his primary issue.  Finally on his 6th pass attempt of the night he sailed a nice ball to the left over the defender and into Eric Lair's waiting hands for a 24 yard game.  Weber finally settled down in the second half and made some good throws, including a nice throw to MarQueis crossing the middle, and a beauty to McKnight on a 3rd and 12 that extended the drive (ultimately leading to the go-ahead score).  And to Weber's credit, he didn't make any major mistakes or turnovers despite MTSU's frequent blitzes.

But overall, there wasn't a whole lot to criticize the offense on.  All three RBs looked good.  Check that -Bennett was phenomenal.  He had terrific burst through the line, and great effort after contact. The frosh Kirkwood was solid, and picked his holes well.   Jon Hoese's play was inspired and it was awesome to see him score the first 3 TDs of the season, given the fact that earlier in the week his traveling with the team was in question due to his father's health.  Right tackle Ed Olson Jr's first career start should be considered a success (although he did get torched on one speed rush).  They even minimized their penalties and the few they did have weren't drive killers.

And the defense? Well if a grade had to be handed out it would probably have to be 'incomplete'.  They simply weren't even on the field long enough for us to conclude too much.  That's what happens when your offense holds the ball for 75% of the game.  From what we did see, it was clear that our young safeties are pretty inexperienced, as they struggled with coverage. The athleticism was there with Manuel and Lewis, but we could certainly stand to have Royston and Theret back soon.  The Blue Raiders ran only 40 plays, but their offense was effective at times in the no-huddle.  I was a little concerned with the lack of pressure our front 4 generated (zero sacks, and really not any hurries either).  The LBs seemed solid initially, but seemed to struggle a little bit with their play diagnosis as the game wore on.  However, in that limited sample size, the Gopher defense did manage a nice tip drill interception (Rallis) and a made a few key 3rd down stops - including a huge TFL by Jewhan Edwards to stifle the last possession by MTSU.  And those positive moments should not be discounted.

So what did we learn on Thursday night?  All kinds of things.  First and foremost I discovered that our coaching staff really does appear to be committed to the run (67 rushing attempts was convincing).  I found that all of MTSU's talk of selling out their home opener was just that, talk (sellout my ass).  I learned that Keanon Cooper has decent wheels - as he ran down RB Phillip Tanner from behind to save a TD.  I learned that Duane Bennett came to Murfreesboro TO PLAY ( and he would have had a nice receiving TD to tack on to his near 200 yds rushing, if on that shovel pass too he would have read his blocks a little quicker). I saw that Ellestad is still struggling from outside of 40 yards (but at least his problem isn't the distance).  And finally, I learned that MTSU's slightly built QB, Logan Kilgore just might have been adopted - judging by the body type of his father and maternal grandfather.

Winning on the road is winning.  Nothing negative about that at all. Still plenty of improvement out there to be made, but there was plenty to be pleased with as well.  Next week - the South Dakota Coyotes come in to The Bank.  So keep an eye on the Coyotes against Central Florida this weekend.  Next Saturday should be a perfect opportunity for the Gophs to tune up their game before USC rolls into town.

Monday, November 16, 2009

SDSU @ Minnesota - What we learned

Deja-NDSU. Ugh.

I'm talking about the 2006 win over the Bison, not the 2007 debacle. The fact that I have to clarify is embarassing enough. We've not done well against teams from the Dakotas in recent history. And last Saturday was no different.

This was one of those wins that was almost impossible to enjoy. All you could do was sit in the stands and wonder if the offense could be any more incompetant, or if the defense would finally falter.

At his press conference last week, Coach Brewster was asked if he still felt games against teams like SDSU had any benefit (transcript). Brew responded: "I feel the same way. I don't know how much it benefits the University of Minnesota to play South Dakota State. I'm not sure of that benefit." I agreed with him when he said that about NDSU two years ago, and I agree now. Why even play these games? They serve no purpose beyond potential embarassment, and they may even be counter-productive to recruiting in the region. If you're going to schedule on of these FBS teams for a game, it has to be somebody outside of the upper midwest. The South and North Dakota States of the world have rosters that appear to have stolen potential walk-ons from across Minnesota. Quality prep football players who could contribute on our roster, would the scholarships (fairly or not) need to go to more highly tauted out-of-state talent. But enough complaining about having to play the Jackrabbits to begin with.

First, let me be positive. Our senior laden defense was stellar all game, actually scoring as many points as they allowed (6). They generated turnovers, and hung tough to get us a win. Cosgrove and Lee had their unit prepared and ready to play. Hats off to them for showing up and gutting out a win on Senior Day. But the offense did these guys no favors. None.

As I stated earlier, this win was painful to sit through. This was almost exclusively the fault of the offense. Whaley disappointed me. The offensive line was dreadful (again), and Adam Weber was as ineffective and awful as I have ever seen him, with the added excitement of another pick-6. How a 3-year college quarterback who is your all-time leader in passing yardage can now routinely complete less than half of his attempted passes is beyond me. Weber managed to string together consecutive completions only once during the entire game (and the second completion was a two yard loss to boot). At this point, there is absolutely no reason for him to start any more. No need to waste Gray's freshman season any longer, right? Some how I doubt the offensive coaching staff will agree.

While reading some of the comments to a rather uninspired sarcastic Strib editorial penned by resident Gopher basher (when Reusse is too busy), Jim Souhan, I found one that got me thinking. The author noted that he didn't belive MarQueis Gray was blue-chip recruit, because a blue-chip recruit would be starting for this team, and speculated that Brewster is either a liar or an idiot for not starting him. Now I DO believe MarQueis is a blue-chipper, and I DON'T think Brewster is an idiot. But the point of this comment is well taken - we're simply not that good of a team where Gray shouldn't be playing all the time. Once the Illinois game was over, the transition to Gray starting with the first team should have been initiated. Gray needs reps if he's to be the QB of the future we expect him to be. Obviously, the situation is complicated by having an experienced upperclassman QB on the roster, but Brewster's leash for Weber has been long enough. I would have preferred for Gray to get his first start against SDSU at home, and admittedly, throwing him to the wolves in Kinnick Stadium seems much less appealing, but if the O-line is going to continuously collapse, then at least have MarQueis in there to try and make something out of nothing with his feet. What's the worst that can happen? 55-0?

So what did we learn on during this embarassing Saturday? Well, I learned that the tailgating scene in the lots around directly adjacent to the stadium is great. I learned that the SDSU football team appears to have ripped their jerseys and color scheme off from San Jose State. I learned that our offense can play worse against a lesser opponent. And finally, I learned that our defense has a lot of pride, and I can say confidently that they'll play tough against Iowa, no matter the awful circumstances the offense will almost inevitably put them in.

Time to try and end the regular season on a high note and get Floyd back. Go Gophers!

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Illinois @ Minnesota - What we learned

While sitting on my sunny perch in Section 219 last Saturday, I realized that in all the game scenarios that ran thru in my mind, I did not process the one where the Illini go into the half up 21 with Juice Williams watching from the sidelines. Yikes. What the hell happened?

For starters, 'Bad Web' wandered back onto campus again, and like he has in games early in this season, it took him a half to really even get warmed up. In fact it was not until 13:40 left in the 3rd quarter before Weber was able to complete consecutive pass attempts. Worse than this though was the 6 points he gift wrapped for the Illini, on a pass that everyone in the stadium gasped at before it even left Weber's hand. His pick-6 to Terry Hawthorne might have been his worst INT of the season, and that's saying something.

But 'Bad Web' is only part of the story. The O-line didn't do him any favors either, as Weber was sacked an unacceptable 7 times. Coming off what I believed was their best pass blocking performance of the year last week, the line as a group regressed again. And their run blocking? Well its hard to say, since Jed Fisch decided that running the ball was not a priority in the first half. I don't usually like to specifically criticize playcalling because its very safe to assume that offensive coordinators at the college level know a hell of a lot more than me. However, I'll make an exception this week - as I feel that the 1st half playcalling was a big reason we couldn't go punch-for-punch with Illinois. Instead of running the ball we decided play-action passes to receivers 30+ yards down field were the way to go. These led to a lot of drive killing incompletions, and often forced us into too many 3rd and longs. By the opening drive of the second half, Fisch seemed to figure out the balance of run-pass, until he had the whole stadium groaning on a play-action pass called on a 2nd and goal from the half yard line. The play resulted in an 8-yard loss (QB sack), and the drive disappointingly ended with a field goal. From that down and distance, a TD seemed imminent, provided we keep handing the ball off to Hoese or Bennett inside the 5. Even working in QB sneak would have been fine. But enough second guessing. By and large, the offense stunk for a variety of reasons, and had Nick Tow-Arnett not come up with some clutch 3rd and long catches (including an absolute beauty down the seam), the mounting 4th quarter near-comeback would not have been a reality.

Assessing the defense is not pleasant either. They gave up 21 first half points, but they made adjustments and held them to just 7 in the 2nd half. Unfortunately, the last Illini TD scored came with 5 minutes left in the 4th, on a long, clock-eating drive. Jason Ford did well running against our front 7, and in the end managed to run the clock out on us. Our secondary was beaten by a freshman back-up QB (Charest), and got exposed repeatedly on 3rd downs when the front 4 couldn't get pressure. It almost seemed like they had gameplanned for Juice so heavily, that when he came out due to injury, they didn't know how to handle a traditional drop-back passer. After the Penn State and OSU games were over, I felt like our defense performed admirably, given their time on the field. But after the this game, I felt like they underperformed in a big way, and arguably gave their worst performance of the season. No major blown coverage in the secondary though, so I suppose that is one positive.

To both the offense and defense's credit, they did keep the penalties down (3 for 22 yards), so it was good to see the Brewster had tightened up on this over the week. Hats off to Keanon Cooper this week too, as he came up with the blocked punt that gave us a chance late in the game. That kid has had a nose for the ball all season, and good things happen when he's on the field (remember the pass breakup late in the game vs. MSU?) - really looking forward to his tenure as an everyday LB.

So what did we learn this week? Well, I discovered that sunny November football games at 'the Bank' will produce a pronounced thermocline down the middle of the stadium, with the fans on the southern half of the bowl kept nice and frigid under the shadow cast by the press box and suites, while the rest of us basked in solar warmth. We learned that we can play relatively penalty football. We learned that play-action passes don't work too well when you don't establish a running game, and they work even less well on the half-yard line when the run blitz is coming. And finally, I learned that fine friends, beautiful weather, and a Surly Furious make losing a football game in November tolerable. Win or lose, it was an absolutely picturesque day to go to 'the Bank'.

Jackrabbits from South Dakota State coming in this weekend, and I'll be there in person again to close out the home schedule. Stay tuned for the SDSU game preview tomorrow.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

Michigan State @ Minnesota – What we learned

Another Gopher victory. It feels good, even if it didn’t look pretty at times. All the penalties, miscues, and big plays aside, conference win number 3 is in the books, friends. And for that we should all be happy. Michigan State was not an opponent to take lightly, and the coaching staff made sure the team didn’t. To me, the game we saw last Saturday night was the kind that a Mason-era led team lost in the 4th quarter. It just had that feel, when MSU took the lead in the 3rd quarter.

But this is Coach Brew’s team, and things seem to be a bit different now. Those nightmarish 4th quarter meltdowns seem to be mercifully fading from my memory. And this game was the one where his recruits and JUCOs helped put their signature on the game. Brandon Green, Da’Jon McKnight, Troy Stoudemire, Keanon Cooper, Simoni Lawrence all chipped in big ways. Which is not to say that the holdovers and recruits from the Mason era were not integral – Weber, Tow-Arnett, Bennett, Campbell, Brown, et al all came up huge, but it felt good to catch more glimpses of the future than just MarQueis.

‘Good Web’ finally showed up again! It’s good to see you bud – stick around for awhile if you would. We were all certainly fearful that ‘Bad Web’ would get worse without Decker to bail him out on 3rd and longs, but about halfway through the game Saturday, I remembered that Weber’s performance without Decker was not unlike the one he had in 2007 on the road at Wisconsin (he threw for 3 TDs and hit 5 different receivers on multiple occasions). So really, we’ve seen him play well without Deck before, but his track-record this year had us all forgetting. Weber couldn’t have put up bigger numbers than he did (well, maybe he could have had Stoudemire hauled in that gimme) on a night we needed it most. And even Weber’s lone gaff, an interception over the middle was also a bit of bad luck, as an official inadvertently set a screen on Da’Jon McKnight. But even then Weber correctly threw to the spot where McKnight would have been. Thanks Adam, you’ve got us believing in you again. Oh, and did anybody notice Weber’s accuracy while wearing a glove on his throwing hand? Strangely impressive.

MarQueis got plenty of snaps this game too, particularly on 2nd downs, where the defense guessing pass or run generally becomes most difficult. I really liked this decision by Fisch. I also appreciated the fact that they almost exclusively run the ball every time he was in (generally a shotgun handoff to Whaley or a QB run), as it seemed to keep Michigan State on their toes. Sadly, Gray’s one really sweet scamper up the sideline was called back on a Kunzia hold. And even though Weber looked really good, I hope we keep utilizing Gray frequently, as it really forces other teams to prepare for two QBs.

The O-line played its best game all year in terms of pass blocking, and gave Weber some massive spans of time to find an open Gopher. Hats off to that unit, and to Tim Davis for having them well prepared.

And in spite of the points yielded by the defense, it was a treat to watch them close the game out, and really limit the Spartan rushing attack (with the exception of that end around to Keyshawn Martin). Blair White was held down all game, and that was huge.

So what did we learn this week? Lots of stuff as always. We learned that Weber can still throw the ball like a top-tier Big Ten QB. We learned that setting a conference record of 17 penalties for 157 yards does not mean you will lose. We learned that our corps of receivers can make plays, and can stuff the stat sheet. We learned that Garrett Brown hustles like no other down D-lineman I’ve seen in recent memory (watch him in the 4th quarter going to the sidelines). And finally, we learned that D’uane Bennet has absolutely exceptional balance (opening TD) and timing (Immaculate Reception Part Deux). Good stuff.

Illinois coming to the Bank this weekend, and I don’t think there is any chance that the coaching staff will allow the team to overlook them, particularly following their dominating win over Michigan. Go Gophers!

Wednesday, October 28, 2009

Gophers @ Buckeyes - What we learned

To paraphrase the always quotable Denny Green, “The Buckeyes are who we thought they were.” That’s how I felt after watching this game. They beat us like a drum like they do every year. And much like the Penn State game, we hung tough with a superior opponent for a 30 minutes. We were one bad play where pass coverage broke down from being all even going into the half. All in all, not a bad place to be when playing Ohio State on the road. Then it all fell apart, and the second half devolved into series turnovers and miscues. The defense which had looked relatively solid in the first two quarters, started to come apart.

There were signs of this in the first half, of course - some bad penalties, the blown coverage on Posey, etc. Even still, with Theret’s pick in the endzone effectively ending the half, I felt good. It seemed like with a few adjustments in the defense, and if the receivers could actually haul the ball in, we had a chance.

So what do we do? We go and get hoodwinked by a pop-up kick, and Stoudemire is caught unawares. Ball goes to OSU and Pryor gallops into the endzone 3 plays later on the short field. For a team that can’t seem to find any way to score points, that became the tipping point.

Fisch reverted the offense back to its fallback formation when we’re down, the shotgun. The run was pretty much abandoned from this point on, with the exception of the designed QB draw. And not much worked from that formation either, (with at least one exception, the nice TE screen we ran to Tow-Arnett). Really though the stat line to remember from the offense is this: 3rd Down converstions 1 for 10. That makes us a sizzling 4 for 21 in the last 2 games. The only thing not completely frustrating to watch on the offense was the play of MarQueis Gray (although he did take a sack in the 3rd quarter that was absolutely terrible). I’ve watched his play in the final offensive drive several times now, and I have to say I was impressed with his accuracy and poise when throwing. Yes, it was against the OSU second-teamers. But he handled a blitz off the edge perfectly, and the timing and velocity of his throws was excellent, especially on the slant pass to Stoudemire for our only TD.

Given the situations the defense was put in during the second half (turnovers leading to very short field scoring opportunities), I thought the defense was at least competent despite the scoreboard. Lee Campbell in particular came to play, and was flying to the ball and hitting hard all day.

So what did we learn from Homecoming at the Horseshoe? Well, we caught a glimpse of the future with Gray under center for a full series, and despite the circumstances, it was nice. And we learned the offense’s commitment to the run is apparently just lip service, and we’ll just duck back into the shotgun at the first sign of difficulty rushing. We learned that Adam Weber doesn’t seem to have any interest in not throwing interceptions. And finalIy we learned that Bob Griese is an even bigger idiot than I thought.

An emotionally depleted Michigan State coming in on All Hallows Eve this Saturday night. Time to get right, and get back over 0.500 – this is a game that can and should be won, especially at home. Preview coming later this week, and possibly a MSU alum (Sparty Tom) take on the game as well. Stay tuned.

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Gophers at Nittany Lions - What we learned

Sigh. This was one of those games you’d like to forget immediately after you watched it. Penn State dominated us all game, particularly their defense. Sometimes you need to have to have a poor short term memory to get over these kinds of losses.

Unfortunately my short-term memory is fine, so we’ll go through this cathartic exercise of breaking down the game a bit and gathering a few lessons learned along the way if we can. Let me stay positive to start things off. The Gopher defense played hard and did as well as could be expected given that they were on the field for 42 minutes. Yeah, that’s not a typo – our defense was on the field for 42 of the 60 minutes played. They started out well enough, holding PSU to a pair of field goals, despite Weber giving up field position via another foolish interception. The long TD drive they gave up at the end of the half (Moye’s excellent catch) was clearly a result of a worn down D, that needed a blow. The second half was much the same. Given the time of possession situation, I’d say we were lucky to get out of there 20 to nothing.

The offense was so absolutely horrid that they couldn’t provide any kind of breather at all for their teammates on the other side of the ball. So I give the defense credit, they played a decent game, despite struggling mightily to stop 3rd down conversions (Penn State was 11 of 17 – ouch).

Talking about the offense is hardly worth my time, as I’m sure all of you saw the carnage that our offensive line allowed to happen. Nothing we ran worked. Our running backs were constantly savaged at the line of scrimmage, and Weber was again wilting under any semblance of pressure. And unlike last week, where Decker’s numbers were down because we simply didn’t need to force the ball to him, in this game we found out that even Decker couldn’t get open fast enough to have Weber throw the ball, before he had to dodge tacklers. Remember how Weber had some pocket-presence when he was a frosh? He’d take some nasty hits that had us gasping, but he’d get the completion. Those days seem so long ago now.

Did Fisch have a plan for the offense if trying to run the ball effectively didn’t work? It sure didn’t look like it. Were we so arrogant to assume we could run the ball on the Lions? I don’t know, but I suppose no gameplan, no matter how brilliant, can succeed when players don’t execute.

So what did we learn from our trip to Beaver Stadium? Well, Penn State’s defense seems mighty good (or our offense is conversely mighty bad), despite the opponents they’ve played. We learned that our defense plays with a lot of heart and pride, but that only goes so far, and they’ve got to catch a breather once in a while (not just at halftime). We learned the coaching staff still isn’t comfortable putting Gray in late in the 4th quarter with the game out of hand (redshirt anyone). And finally I learned that even Troy Stoudemire can be contained from time to time. I’d like to add that I was pretty impressed with the size of the Gopher contingent at the game. It looked like they filled up a pretty decent sized section. Good job road-trippers. We need to see more of that.

And irritated OSU looms ahead, and I’m sure they are expected to get things right at home against the Gophs. I’m curious to know when the last time OSU lost 2 straight games. Seems like it might have been a while (I’ll look that up later this week) That doesn’t seem to bode well for our squad, but stranger things have happened. Go Gophers!